Great Books

Great Books
To read or not to read?....that is a silly question!
Showing posts with label Ewan McGregor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ewan McGregor. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 31, 2014

This time, the movie is better than the book

I decided to read BIG FISH:  A NOVEL OF MYTHIC PROPORTIONS by Daniel Wallace when I first realized that the movie BIG FISH was actually based on a book!  I saw the movie years ago and loved it!  I love Ewan McGregor, you know!  But I had no idea it was a book first.  A few weeks ago, we had a free movie weekend with HBO or something like that and there was a preview, I think, that mentioned the book.  I decided that I wouldn't watch the movie again until I read the book, so I immediately ordered the book and now I've finished reading it!  So I can finally watch the movie again!  

The movie varies from the book quite a bit.  It keeps the essence of the overall story--what Wallace does with this beautiful story of a man who is an amazing story-teller (on his deathbed) and his son, attempting to connect with the man he doesn't know.  

In some ways, I like the book better, but a part of me feels that I'm only saying that because as a book lover, I'm kind of supposed to say that.  It is a really good book and I am very glad that I read it, but yet I have to admit that with this one, I think the movie is better.  I don't know if it's because I'm prejudice towards Ewan McGregor or what, but I just find that the movie is much more fun.  The book is cute, but I didn't laugh or smile or even cry while reading the book.  I did all of those when I watched the movie.  Of course, again, that might be because I watched the movie first, but that isn't going to change my opinion.  

In this instance, the movie BIG FISH is better than the book BIG FISH by Daniel Wallace.  (*Don't hate!)

BTW:  did you know that there is also a stage musical?!  I didn't!